richardf8: (Default)
richardf8 ([personal profile] richardf8) wrote2008-11-30 08:06 pm

Crucified at the crux of greed and envy.

Learned from [livejournal.com profile] level_head who learned it from [livejournal.com profile] rowyn that at a Wal-Mart in Valley Stream, an employee was stampeded to death by a mob awaiting the store's early opening. Do read the story if it is not familiar to you.

Now, where to even begin?

Well, let's see, let's begin on Thanksgiving, when people who were working retail had to be prepared to wake up at 2 or 3AM to be at stores by 4am for 5am openings. Many would have had to have earlier Thanksgiving meals, or given up on it in order to be alert the next day. This was noted by friend Stego.

This is in service of what?

Then there are those 5:00 store openings as well, littered with loss-leaders to entice people into the stores. Heavy discounts on flat screen TV's were common, not just at Wal-Mart, but at Best Buy, and many other outlets across the nation.

This is in service of what?

Then there are the people determined to be first in line, determined to beat their neighbors to those loss-leaders. Instead of getting a good night's sleep and spending the day after Thanksgiving in quality time with family and friends, they're up at God-knows-when so they can get this stuff that no one really needs.

This is in service of what?

There's desperation all over this scenario - the retail worker desperate for a paycheck, the retailer desperate for sales, the consumer desperate for the discount. And all this desperation collided tragically on Friday in Valley Stream, and a man died.

This in service of what?

Ben Zoma would say: "Who is rich, he who is happy with his portion." (Avot 4:11)

If everyone in America followed Ben Zoma, our economy would collapse in a heartbeat. So we live in a world of manufactured need, and discontent with our portion is the engine that drives our economy. And right now, problems in banking and industry are forcing some to learn to be content with their portion, and others to look for bargains that will allow them to assuage their discontent within the constraints imposed by those problems.

Sales like the Black Friday sales are designed to capitalize on the discontent that our culture works so hard to manufacture. And that discontent is a powerful enough force that this year, it killed a man.

[identity profile] deckardcanine.livejournal.com 2008-12-01 03:47 am (UTC)(link)
Everyone who discusses this incident faces the fact that the worship of greed can be more disgusting than any other common worship.

Your repetition between paragraphs somehow reminded me of a butchered "Dayenu" translation, even before you cited Ben Zoma. And as long as I'm thinking Jewish, I'm a little surprised to see you write out "God" instead of censoring part of it.

[identity profile] deckardcanine.livejournal.com 2008-12-01 04:18 am (UTC)(link)
Fair enough. I just thought I'd seen you type "G-d" or a variant like "G*d" in the past.
ext_81845: penelope, my art/character (failure)

[identity profile] childings.livejournal.com 2008-12-01 05:10 am (UTC)(link)
I'm so glad I don't work retail anymore. Also I was sickened to find the woman in the news video blaming the retailers for not being "organized enough".
I can only wish I could have articulated my reaction to the collision of insidious socio-economic memes it took to cause this so coherently. On a personal level, I'm that much less likely to take on faith that being afraid of crowds is irrational. From crowd to mob, there's not always a full step.

[identity profile] locakitty.livejournal.com 2008-12-01 06:09 am (UTC)(link)
I read about that and was absolutely pissed off. Especially when I read that the customers continued to trample through while the EMTs were there trying to save the poor guy.

I think they should pull all the credit card slips and charge everyone of those people with manslaughter, if not murder.

I haven't done Black Friday shopping in a looooong time. Mostly either due to work or the fact that, really, that discount just isn't worth me getting out of bed in the morning when I can hang out with the family. Or watch bad television. Or read. Or so many other things.

The last black friday I worked in retail (read: not food service) was a B&N next to a Best Buy. People were mad at us for not being open at 5 a.m. or earlier (we opened at 8 that day, instead of 9) to sell them coffee. The employees at the Best Buy looked as if they had been through war. I felt bad for them.

That and I hate crowds. As wastrel pointed out, there's not always a full step. Especially when I hear tales from my employees about being out there and getting hit with shopping carts and what not. Ugh.

[identity profile] deckardcanine.livejournal.com 2008-12-02 05:33 pm (UTC)(link)
Not murder if the killing was unintended. In truth, I'm disinclined to shame anyone but the people in front who deliberately broke the doors.

Here's the thing: If you're in a crowd and you see someone getting trampled, you may want to help the person, but you're also aware that the same thing could happen to you if you stop to do so. And then you'll have helped nobody. It's a reasonable fear of the frenzied, unknowingly violent people behind you that propels you forward.

The trick, then, is not to be in the crowd in the first place.

[identity profile] timtylor.livejournal.com 2008-12-01 01:02 pm (UTC)(link)
Just letting my brain freewheel here, but could sales shopping have become a sort of mass sport? I'm thinking a bit of things like medieval "mob football" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mob_football), which by the look of it was a big crowd activity that could also turn very bad (http://www.expertfootball.com/history/soccer_history_mob_football.php). Of course, shopping frenzies are far more individualistic than even the most mobbish team sports. But I'm wondering if excitement and the desire to be caught up in the event might be as much part of this as the simple greed for cheap stuff.